Polkassembly Logo

Create Pencil IconCreate
OpenGov

Notice: Polkadot has migrated to AssetHub. Balances, data, referenda, and other on-chain activity has moved to AssetHub.Learn more

View All Big Spender

OpenGov Argumentree: improve decision quality

inBig Spender
a year ago
Rejected

Overview: Traditional discussion forums, Telegram, Discord, and social media platforms like X (Twitter) fall short in fostering effective and transparent OpenGov debates. These platforms often lack structured debate features, suffer from off-topic discussions, and fail to provide clear visualization of arguments, leading to fragmented and inefficient conversations.

Problem Statement: Current platforms present several issues:

  • Traditional Forums: Lack structured debate tools, make following complex arguments difficult, and struggle with scalability.
  • Social Media: Fragmented discussions, echo chambers, rapid pace inhibiting in-depth responses, misinformation risks, and inadequate moderation.

Proposed Solution: We propose a new discussion forum with features designed to enhance transparency and effectiveness:

  • Structured Debates: Logical organization of arguments with interactive tree structures and easy pro/con identification.
  • Enhanced Navigation: Features for efficient exploration and tracking debate evolution.
  • In-Depth Analysis: Tools for argument evaluation, consensus highlighting, and source integration.
  • Q\&A and Compromise: Dynamic Q\&A sections, real-time voting, and interactive compromise suggestions for collaborative problem-solving.
  • Compromise\&Agreements: Tools for suggesting and evaluating compromises facilitate collaborative problem-solving, benefiting the negotiation process.
  • Proposal Review: Structured layouts for analyzing outcomes, impact assessments, and risk intelligence.
  • Analytics Dashboard: Real-time updates on argument strength and community focus.
  • Timeline Slider: Visualize argument development and discussion shifts over time.
  • Chat Functionality: Direct chat options for discussing arguments in real-time.

Benefits: This platform will streamline discussions, prevent misinformation, enhance transparency, and encourage meaningful engagement by integrating diverse opinions and structured analysis tools. It aims to build a more informed and participative OpenGov community.

Thank you.

Comments (15)

a year ago

Explained here: https://x.com/bitfalls/status/1819763415134408843

a year ago

there is 3 month retroactive full time ask here. can the git log be be inspected somewhere?

Load more comments
PleaseLogin to comment

Requested

DOT
507.50K DOT

Proposal Failed

Help Center

Report an Issue
Feedback
Terms and Conditions
Github

Our Services

Docs
Terms of Website
Privacy Policy

A House of Commons Initiative.

Polka Labs Private Limited 2026

All rights reserved.

Terms and ConditionsTerms of Website
Privacy Policy