Notice: Polkadot has migrated to AssetHub. Balances, data, referenda, and other on-chain activity has moved to AssetHub.Learn more
OpenGov Argumentree: improve decision quality
Overview: Traditional discussion forums, Telegram, Discord, and social media platforms like X (Twitter) fall short in fostering effective and transparent OpenGov debates. These platforms often lack structured debate features, suffer from off-topic discussions, and fail to provide clear visualization of arguments, leading to fragmented and inefficient conversations.
Problem Statement: Current platforms present several issues:
- Traditional Forums: Lack structured debate tools, make following complex arguments difficult, and struggle with scalability.
- Social Media: Fragmented discussions, echo chambers, rapid pace inhibiting in-depth responses, misinformation risks, and inadequate moderation.
Proposed Solution: We propose a new discussion forum with features designed to enhance transparency and effectiveness:
- Structured Debates: Logical organization of arguments with interactive tree structures and easy pro/con identification.
- Enhanced Navigation: Features for efficient exploration and tracking debate evolution.
- In-Depth Analysis: Tools for argument evaluation, consensus highlighting, and source integration.
- Q\&A and Compromise: Dynamic Q\&A sections, real-time voting, and interactive compromise suggestions for collaborative problem-solving.
- Compromise\&Agreements: Tools for suggesting and evaluating compromises facilitate collaborative problem-solving, benefiting the negotiation process.
- Proposal Review: Structured layouts for analyzing outcomes, impact assessments, and risk intelligence.
- Analytics Dashboard: Real-time updates on argument strength and community focus.
- Timeline Slider: Visualize argument development and discussion shifts over time.
- Chat Functionality: Direct chat options for discussing arguments in real-time.
Benefits: This platform will streamline discussions, prevent misinformation, enhance transparency, and encourage meaningful engagement by integrating diverse opinions and structured analysis tools. It aims to build a more informed and participative OpenGov community.
Thank you.
Comments (15)
Requested
Proposal Failed
Summary
0%
Aye
0%
Nay
Aye (9)0.0 DOT
Support0.0 DOT
Nay (93)0.0 DOT
Explained here: https://x.com/bitfalls/status/1819763415134408843
there is 3 month retroactive full time ask here. can the git log be be inspected somewhere?