Auditors Proto-Collective
EDIT:
This proposal was created due to Adam Steeber's request on AAG #117 to have more proposals and ideas for the Kusama DV to crunch on. I discussed these on AAG #119. The purpose of these bounties is to form proto-collectives around ideas in principle. By creating these bounties and segregating this funding it does the following:
- Shows that the community supports an idea in principle which should incentivize people to work toward that idea.
- Allows us to have discussions on structure and mechanisms at a later date
- It reduces the burn on the treasury (We have burned $1.5M on kusama in the last year alone). By putting 50% of the treasury into bounties based on ideas in principle, we reduce the burn rate by 50%.
Stake Plus will not be involved in any of these proto-collectives as either curator or as a member. These are ideas that I've (Tom) had rolling around in my brain and thought I would shoot them out. I look forward to seeing ideas presented by other agents.
If there is a person or team interested in leading this collective, they should put together a proper proposal and apply with that idea along with a full set of curators using the bounty.proposeCurator() extrinsic. If no one steps forward, at minimum we're reducing the burn and these funds can be reaped back to treasury in the future.
The provided proposal document is meant to be a framework of how I was approaching the idea.
This proposal seeks to establish a proto-collective tasked with auditing historical deliverables of Polkadot treasury proposals, ensuring proponents meet their obligations and safeguarding the treasury's assets. It will enable up to 50 independent ecosystem agents to join, with 4 auditors randomly selected for each audit to assess deliverables and generate transparent, JSON-integrated reports for ecosystem-wide governance enhancements.
Proposal: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Sqduurq5GmijupCPSl5W5LwM56O6KrftB5EFM5261Qk/edit?usp=sharing
Comments (4)
Confirmation Period
3
of 3Decision Period
28 / 28 days
Confirmation Period
0 / 7 days
Summary
0%
Aye
0%
Nay
Aye (46)0.0 DOT
Support0.0 DOT
Nay (106)0.0 DOT
Voting Data
Approval%
Support%
Threshold0.00%
Threshold0.00%
Dear Tom,
You've posted three requests to fund bounties with 33,333 KSM each, none of which provide a well defined budgets but rather on-going rates. US$125/hr is quite a lot for un-tethered curation spending. Have the curators been identified so we can attest this rate to their expertise?
I understand the flexibility that bounties provide but with that flexibility can come unhindered spending if not well planned.
I identify with the problem you're trying to address and I am also working on a solution to address this. I am doing so at my own cost and later intend to seek funding from the treasury after there's proven results.
Even in my wildest dreams I can not see myself asking for 1.5 million USD for the programme which includes development and funding participants and dare I say my thoughts on how to achieve this are more well formed.
Please think this through more and take some risk.
I've decided to vote AYE on 365, 366, and 367. This is exactly what I wanted to see - broad spending categories in the form of bounties.
I believe this is a great way to rouse leaders in the ecosystem to step up and provide a more clear structure for these programs. By approving these bounties, we are simply earmarking the funds for a broad purpose - we aren't approving a proposed curation of these funds. That will come when people in the community submit their own
bounties.proposeCurator
referenda. That's when my level of scrutiny will increase - I expect teams to seriously compete to become curators under these bounties. Competition almost always generates higher quality outcomes.I don't even think we need to take Tom's guidelines as the "law" for these bounties. Ultimately, whoever tries to become a curator under these bounties will be responsible for making commitments on wages, deliverables, and other expectations.
This is exactly how bounties should be used. And being that this is Kusama, we need to push the experimentation and Chaos.