Hey Team,

I will also be voting against this proposal for the reasons mentioned on the discussion post.

- Version 1 which received 80kUSD funding is disappointing (poor value for money)

- Project asks for upfront payment of large amount (200k USD)

- Payment not tied to ROI for chain

- As proposal stands all risk is put on the treasury

- Project builds on outdated/last generation tech that may potentially be obsolete by time of release

You seem to have rushed with the on-chain creation of this proposal by only leaving it up for discussion and community feedback for 4 days.

Hey Kusamahub team,

Thank you for the proposal.

Here's the [referendum audit](https://crustipfs.art/ipfs/QmYE5rb11T9rVQ6YWoanEZg44N9GsHm87VhhwuEsMCkQyg) for this treasury proposal.

**Notes**
- This audit was not influenced by previous audits.
- This audit reflects only the quality of information presented in the proposal and not the Quality of the project/idea itself.

![Kusamahub Kusama dictionary](https://crustipfs.art/ipfs/QmPu9PXKFB43sqT4ApEBS37U6swT4gT7NSDPKi7LiHGtGr)

The following proposal Audit is created as a part of the extension for [Proposal#67](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/post/2431). More information about the Treasury proposal template and the Audit process can be found on the link above. All templates are free for everyone to use. For any questions or feedback regarding the Audit templates use the discussion link from above.

Hello KusamaHub,

I'm strongly voting **Nay** for this for 2 simple reasons without going into too much detail:

1. You have not delivered the initial proposal, [here](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/treasury/200)

2. You have a lot of guts for asking for over $200k upfront claiming team expansion. 

If I were you, I would work my ass off (overtime if needed and with the staff I have) and deliver the first proposal and then come back to the treasury and request milestone funding to show accountability.

Right now it's nothing but a red flag + not waiting for a full week in discussions which shows rushing to get that sweet honey pot of KSM as Gabriel stated above..

While we appreciate the effort put into this project, we have decided to reject it at this time. The main reasons for this decision are the high funding amount requested and the short discussion period prior to the voting stage. We believe that it is important for proposals to have enough time for discussion and feedback from the community before reaching the voting stage, and in this case, the three-day discussion period was not sufficient. Additionally, the requested funding amount is higher than what we consider reasonable for the proposed scope of work. We encourage you to continue refining your proposal and submitting it again in the future with a longer discussion period and a more reasonable funding amount.

Dear Kusama Hub,

I'm voting nay as I don't believe that you've delivered on your previous proposal.

Regards,

Hello Community! 


In the last 6 months, all the **KusamaHub** team worked hard to keep up with all the request from different projects and teams and we mainly focused on the Back-End side to cover all the aspects of our platform. Finally you can start seeing the results of our work!

You can find the first Beta Version here: [https://beta.kusamahub.com/](https://beta.kusamahub.com/)

Our next proposal aim to cover the next 6 months of development for **KusamaHub**, where we want to expand our team to provide within the next months a product ready to be used for anyone in the community while keep helping projects with development tools and bots to help them improve awareness, interest and availability of the information related to their projects.

Full Proposal can be found here: [KusamaHub 2' Proposal](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Kr9HZk1sG9cFW2eTCNiKJLMbuDA0M2KCPChfo_Hl0iQ/edit?usp=sharing)

Our GitHub: [KusamaHub](https://github.com/kusamahub)

Costs Breakdown: [Costs Breakdown](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jVC8S_7UrxzQVFmiWkDITrNCKOwazQcqsNRNY8XmXyM/edit?usp=sharing)

We decided also to change the format of our development in a more transparent-efficient way where anybody can see the tasks we are working on in real time in our Trello account open for the community. (Coming soon)

Another improvement we’re doing is that we’ve opened the requests for the existing Project that need help with the set-up of bots and tools in their DC Servers, or for Projects that need some development of some particular instruments. 
We’ll do our best, please keep in mind our priority is develop useful solution for everybody.

So if you’re a project owner and you need help, feel free to complete this simple module and we’ll get back to you within 2 business day. 

Google form here: [Form](https://forms.gle/fXLv4xBmm2dMupBw8)


As you can notice in the Proposal Documents we listened the suggestion of the community, so keep sending us useful feedbacks and suggestions and we’ll make sure to implement these features on **KusamaHub**!



**Useful links:**

**Contatcs:**

Twitter: [https://twitter.com/kusamahub](https://twitter.com/kusamahub)

Email: [kusamahub@gmail.com](kusamahub@gmail.com) 

Telegram: [t.me/kusamahub](t.me/kusamahub)

**Library:**

Original Discussion: [https://kusama.polkassembly.io/post/2531](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/post/2531)

1^ Proposal: [https://kusama.polkassembly.io/treasury/200](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/treasury/200)

Github: [https://github.com/KusamaHub/KusamaHub](https://github.com/KusamaHub/KusamaHub)

Demo: [demo.kusamahub.com](https://demo.kusamahub.com)

1^ Beta: [beta.kusamahub.com](https://beta.kusamahub.com)

Web: [https://kusamahub.com/](https://kusamahub.com/)

Tasks: [Miro](https://miro.com/app/board/uXjVPjWP_-Y=/?share_link_id=596265296959)



Propose and approve a spend of treasury funds.

- `origin`: Must be `SpendOrigin` with the `Success` value being at least `amount`.
- `amount`: The amount to be transferred from the treasury to the `beneficiary`.
- `beneficiary`: The destination account for the transfer.

NOTE: For record-keeping purposes, the proposer is deemed to be equivalent to the
beneficiary.

Requested: 0.61 undefined

#142 Treasury Proposal: KusamaHub 2' Proposal for Continued Operations and Development